Where is Scotty? DialIdol says #1, WhatNotToSing says dead last!

Preliminary WhatNotToSing.com Web Ratings 04/20/2011

Here is an interesting contradiction tonight from two of my favorite online American Idol sites. DialIdol.com has Scotty McCreery as the top vote getter and the safest contestant, but WhatNotToSing.com has him dead last among the seven contestants for his performance tonight. So even though most online bloggers think he had the worst performance of the evening he is still the least likely person to go home. Even checking Idol Chatter's poll of who will be eliminated, Scotty is number three in who should be eliminated, but he is a very distant #3. He is just barely ahead of Haley Reinhart in who should be eliminated, and she is considered to have had the best performance this week by the blogosphere. Since you really cannot vote somebody off American Idol, I am pretty sure Scotty will not be eliminated tomorrow, and he will probably not even be in the bottom three.
All signs seem to point to Stefano Langone going home this week, but you never really know what will happen. The bigger question is who the other two contestants will be that stand with Stefano tomorrow night in the bottom three. Jacob Lusk will probably be there but who else? Haley? Casey? Can Lauren, James and Scotty be safe forever?