American Idol Season 12 Top 5 : Morning After Numbers


I was curious if Season 12 "post Lazaro" would still have the same voting activity after the last male contestant left  the show. In terms of total votes cast on DialIdol from last week and this week, the total number actually slightly increased,  from 18.66K to 18.89K. But interestingly with about the same number of votes over 10 instead of 12 phone lines, the number of busy signals actually dropped down, from 313 last week to only 192 this week. And this week Angie Miller did not have the highest number of busy signals, it was Kree Harrison this time with 43 + 26 = 69 total busy signals. Angie was just barely in second with 44 + 12 = 56, with Amber Holcomb almost tied with her at 32 + 32 = 55 busy signals. Here is my graph of the busy signal counts since Top 10 week. Angie (red column) has always been one of the two contestants with the most busy signals, but for the second week in a row now she has been #2 (she was behind Lazaro last week!) The yellow column notes the number of busy signals for the other contestant in the Top 2 busy signal receivers for the week. Note that Top 6 week was the first one with two lines for each contestant.
Candice Glover again only received 9 + 0 = 9 total busy signals, much less than her 31+37 = 68 last week despite having over 3.8K DialIdol votes this week compared to 3.2K last week. And Janelle Arthur received only 2 + 1 = 3 busy signals out of her 2K votes for the week (compared to a whopping 7 busy signals with over 3K DialIdol votes last week.) With her 2K total votes, Janelle had the lowest number of DialIdol votes this week whereas Amber and Lazaro had fewer total raw votes last week. That cannot be good news for Janelle!

The WhatNotToSing ratings does not bring Janelle any good news either. Without Lazaro to cement down the basement of bad performances, Janelle's ratings of 36 and 40 do not look too promising in comparison. All the other contestants mixed up stronger and weaker performances. If we average the two performances for each contestant:

  1. Candice: 74 + 65 = 139 => 69.5 Average
  2. Kree: 68 + 63 = 131 => 65.5 Average
  3. Angie: 73 + 51 = 124 => 62 Average
  4. Amber: 70 + 41 = 111 => 55.5 Average
  5. Janelle: 40 + 36 = 76 => 38 Average

If we compare this to the averages for last week:
This is not looking to good for Janelle, especially not performing second.